Six Cannabis Grow Methods Compared: HWGrow Project Setup

Short answer: the Meta Soil Project put six popular cannabis growing approaches into one room so I could see how they behaved under the same light and environment. I wanted to compare the work, cost, plant response and tradeoffs of each method.

Video chapters

1. 0:19 — The Meta Soil Project goal
2. 0:29 — Keeper selection and closely matched clones
3. 0:40 — Mr. Canucks, 420 Scene, BuildASoil and Coco for Cannabis
4. 1:02 — TPS Nutrients and Great Lakes Water Only Soil
5. 1:27 — What I tried to keep consistent
6. 1:45 — What the project was designed to teach
7. 2:09 — Transparency and the grow journal

Timestamp links open the standard HWGrow pop-out player at the selected moment without moving you away from your reading position.

The six methods in the comparison

What I tried to control

The clones entered the project at similar sizes and shared the same tent, light cycle and general room conditions. I also limited each method to the nutrients or amendments listed in its own breakdown. That makes the comparison easier to follow, but “same room” does not mean every root zone experienced the same moisture, nutrition or light at every moment.

If you are choosing a medium today, the clearer starting point is Cannabis Soil vs. Coco: How to Choose a Growing Medium. It turns the project into a decision guide instead of pretending one method wins every category.

Tools that make a side-by-side grow easier to read

Waterproof plant labelsKeep every plant, pot, feed record and sample tied to the correct method.Check Current OptionsView product

Matching fabric potsUse the same labeled volume when container size is not the variable you want to test.Check Current OptionsView product

EC/PPM meterRecord solution strength and runoff trends instead of comparing nutrient labels alone.Check Current OptionsView product

Independent temperature/RH meterTrack the shared environment and note where placement creates a different microclimate.Check Current OptionsView product

Affiliate disclosure: HWGrow may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases at no additional cost to you. Equivalent tools can replace the linked products without changing the comparison method.

Frequently asked questions

Was this a controlled scientific experiment?

It was a documented side-by-side grow, with several variables held similar on purpose.

Which growing method is best?

The best method depends on the grower’s available time, measurement habits, water quality, container size and willingness to correct problems. Use the detailed reviews and the soil-versus-coco guide to match a method to your room.

Why use clones in a medium comparison?

Closely matched clones reduce some genetic variation. Rooting, plant position and early health can still make a difference.