Short answer: in my 2022 strain hunt, the prettiest flower was not automatically my favorite smoke—and the strongest overall keeper was not the winner in every category. Running several selections together made structure, stability, finish time, aroma and actual cured experience much easier to compare.

This is a documented grow, not a universal ranking. The numbered selections came from different genetic sources, did not receive perfectly individualized treatment and were judged partly by my own cured-flower experience. “Frosty” is not a laboratory THC result, and one grow cannot prove how every seed from a line will perform.
The complete 2022 strain-hunt case study from the starting plants through the cured comparison. English captions are available from the CC menu.

Video chapters

  1. 0:19 — Why I waited for the cure
  2. 0:47 — Clones and Selfie Seeds™ selections
  3. 1:02 — Soil, tent and light used
  4. 1:49 — Vegetative growth and feed
  5. 2:07 — Why I flipped early
  6. 2:22 — Structure, stability and feeding differences
  7. 4:31 — Pollinated lower branches and staged harvest
  8. 5:12 — Ten-day dry and four-month cure
  9. 5:51 — Selections 1 and 2
  10. 6:24 — Selections 3 through 5
  11. 7:02 — Selection 6 wins the overall score
  12. 7:47 — Final takeaways

Timestamp links open the standard HWGrow pop-out player at the selected moment without losing your reading position.

What I was actually testing

This was a keeper hunt, not a yield-max run. I started with clones from two growers plus three selections from Selfie Seeds™, then ran them together in fabric pots. I flipped earlier than I normally would because the goal was to expose differences without spending extra months filling the tent.

My keeper scorecard:

  • Sexual stability and overall plant health
  • Branch strength and trainable structure
  • Finish time and flower density
  • Aroma, flavor and cured experience
  • Trim workload and leaf-to-flower ratio
  • Yield within this specific room and timeline

Every plant sharing one program is useful for comparison, but it is also a limitation. Different cultivars can prefer different feed strength, light intensity and irrigation timing. I adjusted when the plants showed problems, which helped the run finish well but means this was not a perfectly controlled experiment.

What separated the selections

Selection What stood out in this grow Decision
1 Dense, frosty flower with a balanced sweet-and-funky profile. Strong all-around result.
2 Less visual appeal, but my favorite flavor and personal smoke experience. Personal favorite, even without winning the scorecard.
3 Expressed hermaphroditic flowers during the run. Removed to protect the rest of the room.
4 Frosty flower, good flavor and a heavier subjective effect. Good, but not the overall keeper.
5 Tall structure, earlier flower development and a sweet orange profile. Useful fast-finishing traits, but less ideal structure for my goal.
6 Best combination of yield, visible resin, potency experience and overall performance. Overall winner for this project.
7–8 Weaker final flower quality and less interesting aroma/effect in this run. Not retained.

The biggest lesson: define “best” before you start

If flavor matters most, Selection 2 could have won. If fast finish mattered most, Selection 5 deserved more weight. Selection 6 won because my scorecard prioritized the strongest overall combination. Decide what you are selecting for before the flowers impress you, then keep notes so the goal does not move after harvest.

Use the strain-selection guide before starting and the drying and curing workflow before making the final comparison. A rushed sample can make the wrong plant look like the winner.

Useful strain-hunt tools

Affiliate disclosure: HWGrow may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases at no additional cost to you. Selfie Seeds™ is HWGrow’s in-house genetics source. Equivalent supplies can replace the linked products without changing the comparison method. Verify local laws before ordering or growing cannabis.

New to the full grow workflow? Continue with the complete beginner guide from seed to harvest. For a room-specific selection question, Ask HWGrow.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a strain hunt and a pheno hunt?

A strain hunt compares different genetic lines; a pheno hunt compares multiple individuals from the same line. Both need clear labels and a scorecard.

Which selection won the 2022 HWGrow strain hunt?

Selection 6 won the overall project score because it combined yield, visible resin, potency experience and performance. Selection 2 was still my personal favorite smoke.

Why wait until after curing to choose a keeper?

Aroma, harshness, moisture balance and the subjective experience can change during curing. Judging immediately after drying can reward the wrong plant.

Does visible frost prove high THC?

No. Visible resin is useful observational data, but only validated laboratory testing can quantify cannabinoid content.

Related HWGrow guides: Follow the project decision trail in the late-flower elimination update, then use the cannabis smoke-report template to compare the finished flower consistently.


Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are you human? Please solve:Captcha


You may also like